Post a reply

How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

My regular playing partner is the typical ‘social player’ - likes a chat, doesn’t make any effort to understand the game or improve his ability, probably makes a 20 on his best day. I’d like him to improve, because it’s dragging my game down, but I don’t think he’s receptive to any coaching in the traditional sense. He doesn’t care about improving, so I want to ‘force’ his development without him feeling like a subject of examination.

I’m going to suggest to him we play a frame or two just with the colours on the table. Rules are that if you pot a ball you lose, and if you foul you lose. On the off chance he enjoys it, I think this might get him to think about the white rather than just potting balls, and hopefully translate into an overall improvement in his game.

There was another game I played years ago - I think it was called Scrub (if I remember right). Completely forgotten the rules, but that was also about being clever with the white and it was great at sharpening you up tactically. Pretty sure that was just played with the colours, as well.

I don’t know if anyone plays/played Scrub, or if you know any similar games that focus more on the tactical/positional aspects of snooker, but if so it’d be interesting to learn a bit more!

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby RunningSide

Interesting post,could easily be talking about my sessions with my mate. We are both in late sixties and played for over 40 years. Like your mate mine goes for nearly everything usually at the wrong pace,no thought of percentage play. We get on great and don't think we could upset each other. A few weeks ago I said if I don't knock a 30+ in I'm considering packing up. He suggested playing for £2 a frame and high breaks 50p per point. I said don't want to put strain on relationship but he said let's try,best of 3 see what happens. Strangely standard improved for both, and we now have 4 frames no money involved, followed by bof7 money match.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Holden Chinaski

RunningSide wrote:Interesting post,could easily be talking about my sessions with my mate. We are both in late sixties and played for over 40 years. Like your mate mine goes for nearly everything usually at the wrong pace,no thought of percentage play. We get on great and don't think we could upset each other. A few weeks ago I said if I don't knock a 30+ in I'm considering packing up. He suggested playing for £2 a frame and high breaks 50p per point. I said don't want to put strain on relationship but he said let's try,best of 3 see what happens. Strangely standard improved for both, and we now have 4 frames no money involved, followed by bof7 money match.

This is a great idea.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby RunningSide

Holden Chinaski wrote:
RunningSide wrote:Interesting post,could easily be talking about my sessions with my mate. We are both in late sixties and played for over 40 years. Like your mate mine goes for nearly everything usually at the wrong pace,no thought of percentage play. We get on great and don't think we could upset each other. A few weeks ago I said if I don't knock a 30+ in I'm considering packing up. He suggested playing for £2 a frame and high breaks 50p per point. I said don't want to put strain on relationship but he said let's try,best of 3 see what happens. Strangely standard improved for both, and we now have 4 frames no money involved, followed by bof7 money match.

This is a great idea.

Still worried if I had a Murphy type session, much lower breaks obviously weather things could go wrong.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

Decent suggestion, RS. But I don’t think that’d work in his case. There’s already a big difference in ability, and it’s not that he’s capable of playing better and just can’t be bothered to concentrate - he’s not capable of playing any better because he doesn’t yet grasp the basics. He treats it like a game of pool and isn’t really interested in getting better. Therefore I need him to learn without him feeling like he’s being coached.

Every shot he plays is guesswork. But I don’t want to stand over him every shot because he’ll quickly get fed up with that. Hence the approach.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

Dan-cat wrote:I think you need another snooker bud.


You’re probably right. Mate I played with before him also started off pretty crap, but he had an interest in snooker and wanted to get better. He went from a 20 break to a 60 odd in a couple of years, and we had some great games. He’s now moved in with his bird and nobody sees anything of him :roll:

I went down on my own before Christmas, did a few line ups, just to get my arm in. It’s still in there somewhere.

Anyway, you’re right. I need to start playing some of the ton players. It’s the only way I’ll improve, or at least get back to a decent level. Unfortunately the club isn’t anywhere near as busy as it used to be, and you don’t see the proper players down there like you used to. At least it’s still open!

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Dan-cat

If he has no interest in improving, it's difficult to see how you will get him motivated.

The old guys I play pool with on a Tuesday night, are not very good really. I have recently had a rude awakening, playing in a club in a resort called Javea. I thought I was brilliant, because I'm the star of Tuesday nights, but I realise now they give me so many chances it's too easy. So yes, I make brilliant clearances, but that might be my 5th or 6th visit to the table.

Fast forward to this new club, and players will often clear from the break, or the second or third visit. But it's only taken me a few weeks to get more clinical. My improvement has been rapid. It's so true, that old adage, that you can only improve by playing better players. Last week I did two one-visits from my first shot, in a row. In this club the table is free, you put your names on the board. Sometimes there are 6 or 7 players waiting, and I love this extra pressure - if you lose you are sat down for 45 mins - an hour before your next game.

Do a Facebook post or similar Prop - I bet there are loads of players would be up for meeting regularly and give you a better game. I think you'd be surprised.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

Yep, and you can apply that rule to anything, not just snooker or pool.

We’re booked in for Sunday morning anyway. I’m going to see how the colours game goes. I won’t mention my intentions, just see if something clicks with his cue ball. If he enjoys it, I’ll see it as a step in the right direction.

Facebook - never used it, never will.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Dan-cat

Prop wrote:Yep, and you can apply that rule to anything, not just snooker or pool.

We’re booked in for Sunday morning anyway. I’m going to see how the colours game goes. I won’t mention my intentions, just see if something clicks with his cue ball. If he enjoys it, I’ll see it as a step in the right direction.

Facebook - never used it, never will.


Ok then how to find players? There must be a way!

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

Dan-cat wrote:
Prop wrote:Yep, and you can apply that rule to anything, not just snooker or pool.

We’re booked in for Sunday morning anyway. I’m going to see how the colours game goes. I won’t mention my intentions, just see if something clicks with his cue ball. If he enjoys it, I’ll see it as a step in the right direction.

Facebook - never used it, never will.


Ok then how to find players? There must be a way!


I’m getting a flight to Spain. Heard there’s some guy goes by the name of The Big Cat of Valencia :chin: Apparently he’s different gravy, so I’m heading over to do a few exhibitions with him.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Dan-cat

Prop wrote:
Dan-cat wrote:
Prop wrote:Yep, and you can apply that rule to anything, not just snooker or pool.

We’re booked in for Sunday morning anyway. I’m going to see how the colours game goes. I won’t mention my intentions, just see if something clicks with his cue ball. If he enjoys it, I’ll see it as a step in the right direction.

Facebook - never used it, never will.


Ok then how to find players? There must be a way!


I’m getting a flight to Spain. Heard there’s some guy goes by the name of The Big Cat of Valencia :chin: Apparently he’s different gravy, so I’m heading over to do a few exhibitions with him.


Always welcome!!

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

Dan-cat wrote:
Prop wrote:
Dan-cat wrote:
Prop wrote:Yep, and you can apply that rule to anything, not just snooker or pool.

We’re booked in for Sunday morning anyway. I’m going to see how the colours game goes. I won’t mention my intentions, just see if something clicks with his cue ball. If he enjoys it, I’ll see it as a step in the right direction.

Facebook - never used it, never will.


Ok then how to find players? There must be a way!


I’m getting a flight to Spain. Heard there’s some guy goes by the name of The Big Cat of Valencia :chin: Apparently he’s different gravy, so I’m heading over to do a few exhibitions with him.


Always welcome!!


Ledge! :hatoff:

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby mantorok

Pink Ball wrote:You could turn it into a game of Saw. Nothing focusses the mind like the threat of extreme violence or even death.


You could be onto something here, every ball you pot is placed into a sock, at the end of the game you each get a chance to smash the sock with your accumulated balls into the face of your opponent.

That should inspire them <ok>

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

Pink Ball wrote:You could turn it into a game of Saw. Nothing focusses the mind like the threat of extreme violence or even death.


There’s a threat of respiratory illness from the mouldy walls, so we’re on the right track.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

mantorok wrote:
Pink Ball wrote:You could turn it into a game of Saw. Nothing focusses the mind like the threat of extreme violence or even death.


You could be onto something here, every ball you pot is placed into a sock, at the end of the game you each get a chance to smash the sock with your accumulated balls into the face of your opponent.

That should inspire them <ok>


“Where’s ya tools?”
“What tools?!”

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby mantorok

Prop wrote:
mantorok wrote:
Pink Ball wrote:You could turn it into a game of Saw. Nothing focusses the mind like the threat of extreme violence or even death.


You could be onto something here, every ball you pot is placed into a sock, at the end of the game you each get a chance to smash the sock with your accumulated balls into the face of your opponent.

That should inspire them <ok>


“Where’s ya tools?”
“What tools?!”


rofl

Love that film.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby SnookerEd25

Prop wrote:
Pink Ball wrote:You could turn it into a game of Saw. Nothing focusses the mind like the threat of extreme violence or even death.


There’s a threat of respiratory illness from the mouldy walls, so we’re on the right track.


pmsl

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby rekoons

As already mentioned if the will to improve or learn isn’t there, it’ll be difficult to force (unnoticed).

Even if someone has that desire, they then would still have to realize and accept that it’s bloody difficult, will take time, will require more focus and attention to details they never knew existed, the one step back and 2 steps forward principle, ‘boring’ routines to get basics (cueball control) right,…. And so on and so on…You get the idea.

For most folks it’s just not worth it. I’ve got a mate who’s got some talent I believe, but just doesn’t care to practice because of the ‘boring factor’.

Practice with like-minded players, a little less good or better than yourself.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

rekoons wrote:As already mentioned if the will to improve or learn isn’t there, it’ll be difficult to force (unnoticed).

Even if someone has that desire, they then would still have to realize and accept that it’s bloody difficult, will take time, will require more focus and attention to details they never knew existed, the one step back and 2 steps forward principle, ‘boring’ routines to get basics (cueball control) right,…. And so on and so on…You get the idea.

For most folks it’s just not worth it. I’ve got a mate who’s got some talent I believe, but just doesn’t care to practice because of the ‘boring factor’.

Practice with like-minded players, a little less good or better than yourself.


Yep, can’t disagree.

Tbh the thread was more about discussing games like Scrub (I keep calling it that and I might be wrong). Things that might feel like a novelty to him but take the potting out of the game.

I know I’d be better playing someone at my level, but at this point in my playing days I probably value friendship over getting my game back. It’s still important to me that I don’t completely lose my ability to play, but there’s more value to me in encouraging my friend to improve than there is in focusing solely on myself.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby rekoons

I remember a game I once played involving every player (more than 2 possible) tossing a few coins on the table, if you maneuvered the white so it rolled over or touched a coin, it’s yours.

Don’t remember the details, so don’t know if you had to pot a ball AND touch a coin, or not. Or if there were other rules.

Could make it more attractive to consider the path of the white?

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Juddernaut88

One of my mates that I play with like once a month or so texted me yesterday letting me know he made a 56 break in a match in a tournament at my snooker club. That has been one of his targets for the past year or so making a 50+ break, quite impressive for him to do it in an actual tournament though. I'm not looking forward to giving him a game any time soon!

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

rekoons wrote:I remember a game I once played involving every player (more than 2 possible) tossing a few coins on the table, if you maneuvered the white so it rolled over or touched a coin, it’s yours.

Don’t remember the details, so don’t know if you had to pot a ball AND touch a coin, or not. Or if there were other rules.

Could make it more attractive to consider the path of the white?


Sounds interesting <ok>

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

Juddernaut88 wrote:One of my mates that I play with like once a month or so texted me yesterday letting me know he made a 56 break in a match in a tournament at my snooker club. That has been one of his targets for the past year or so making a 50+ break, quite impressive for him to do it in an actual tournament though. I'm not looking forward to giving him a game any time soon!


You should be looking forward to it! It’ll make you a better player. Do you usually both start on 0 points when you play each other? Pretty common practice in the amateur game to play to a handicap, so maybe he gives you a 20 start next time?

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Juddernaut88

Prop wrote:
Juddernaut88 wrote:One of my mates that I play with like once a month or so texted me yesterday letting me know he made a 56 break in a match in a tournament at my snooker club. That has been one of his targets for the past year or so making a 50+ break, quite impressive for him to do it in an actual tournament though. I'm not looking forward to giving him a game any time soon!


You should be looking forward to it! It’ll make you a better player. Do you usually both start on 0 points when you play each other? Pretty common practice in the amateur game to play to a handicap, so maybe he gives you a 20 start next time?


We usually just play it normally. I may ask for a handicap next time. I can usually take a frame or 2 off him but now it looks like he may have improved even more since I last played him which means getting 1 frame off him will be even trickier.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby Prop

Juddernaut88 wrote:
Prop wrote:
Juddernaut88 wrote:One of my mates that I play with like once a month or so texted me yesterday letting me know he made a 56 break in a match in a tournament at my snooker club. That has been one of his targets for the past year or so making a 50+ break, quite impressive for him to do it in an actual tournament though. I'm not looking forward to giving him a game any time soon!


You should be looking forward to it! It’ll make you a better player. Do you usually both start on 0 points when you play each other? Pretty common practice in the amateur game to play to a handicap, so maybe he gives you a 20 start next time?


We usually just play it normally. I may ask for a handicap next time. I can usually take a frame or 2 off him but now it looks like he may have improved even more since I last played him which means getting 1 frame off him will be even trickier.


Yep, it’s a good position for you to be in. Obviously winning means something to you, so if you use a handicap you shouldn’t get fed up by losing all the time. But the main thing is getting that sense of progress as your game slowly improves. Play for that, try and enjoy it, and you can’t go far wrong.

Re: How to encourage a social player to improve their game

Postby acesinc

Prop wrote:...
Tbh the thread was more about discussing games like Scrub (I keep calling it that and I might be wrong). Things that might feel like a novelty to him but take the potting out of the game.
...



Hi, Prop. I never heard of Scrub before, but I have an interest in alternative forms of the game. On an American Pool forum once, a member once describes a billiards table well I think as being akin to a deck of cards....there are many variations that can be derived using the same simple tools. It might have been BadSnookerPlayer on this forum that I am thinking of.

There used to be a website dedicated to the variations, now sadly defunct as the keeper decided it was time to retire. Fortunately for us, some genius came up with the concept of the "Wayback Machine" which, if you haven't heard of it before, maintains copies of websites for posterity. I have no idea how this works technically, but here is a link that I hope will take you directly there....

http://web.archive.org/web/20190926084343/http://www.snookergames.co.uk/games5.html


If that doesn't work, Google "wayback machine" then just put "snookergames.co.uk" in its search box, then go to the "Games" pages to find Scrub. There are two different rulesets there....first "official" rules from the author's website, then he also posted a commenter's alternate rules for the game. Maybe one of them is the one you remember.


For my part, at a pub, I learned a variation from a bloke that I think was very helpful to me to learn control of the White. It was name "Call Colours" or something like that. The idea is very simple. BEFORE playing at your Red, you must verbally declare WHICH COLOUR you will be playing at should you pot your Red. You can also declare "safety" if you have no intention of potting Red (or just don't say anything), but if you happen to fluke a Red on such stroke, you have lost your turn (but you do get the 1 point for Red). Lastly, there are times that maybe two colours are close together so your intent is to place White somewhere near them and pick whichever happens to be best for the situation. With that in mind, you also get up to three "double calls" in the frame....for instance, you can call "Pink or Blue", then play either of those if you pot Red. ONLY THREE TIMES, though, even if you miss your Red, you have used one of your double calls. I think this puts you in a mindset to always be cognizant of the path of the White and where it is likely to come to rest, so that eventually, the muscle memory will learn the path and strength required.