by Juddernaut88 » 28 Nov 2021 Read
It's a foul for me.
-
Juddernaut88
- Posts: 54559
- Joined: 27 February 2020
- Location: Coventry
- Snooker Idol: Hendry and Trump
- Highest Break: 30
- Walk-On: Simple Minds- Glittering Prize
-
by James Bentley » 28 Nov 2021 Read
The referee had called that Craigie had won the frame before he put his cue down, so the frame was over, wasn't it?
-
James Bentley
- Posts: 2059
- Joined: 06 April 2021
- Snooker Idol: Steve Davis
- Highest Break: 61
- Walk-On: The Go! Team - Junior Kickstart
by Scooper » 28 Nov 2021 Read
I assumed that was a mid frame incident, but since the frame is basically over, doesn’t seem as important somehow. Would ding fans really be happy if he won the frame off that?
-
Scooper
- Posts: 4803
- Joined: 15 February 2016
by Iranu » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:I assumed that was a mid frame incident, but since the frame is basically over, doesn’t seem as important somehow. Would ding fans really be happy if he won the frame off that?
The foul would have left Ding four points behind with pink and black on.
-
Iranu
- Posts: 41485
- Joined: 24 January 2010
- Walk-On: Fort Knox - Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
by Scooper » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Iranu wrote:Scooper wrote:I assumed that was a mid frame incident, but since the frame is basically over, doesn’t seem as important somehow. Would ding fans really be happy if he won the frame off that?
The foul would have left Ding four points behind with pink and black on.
But if he then won, can’t imagine I’d feel great about winning a frame like that
-
Scooper
- Posts: 4803
- Joined: 15 February 2016
by Iranu » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:Iranu wrote:Scooper wrote:I assumed that was a mid frame incident, but since the frame is basically over, doesn’t seem as important somehow. Would ding fans really be happy if he won the frame off that?
The foul would have left Ding four points behind with pink and black on.
But if he then won, can’t imagine I’d feel great about winning a frame like that
Why not?
-
Iranu
- Posts: 41485
- Joined: 24 January 2010
- Walk-On: Fort Knox - Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
by Scooper » 28 Nov 2021 Read
The fact that the frame was clearly over before the careless cue contact ie. white wasn’t going to go in off or anything
-
Scooper
- Posts: 4803
- Joined: 15 February 2016
by McManusFan » 28 Nov 2021 Read
I would love to win a frame like that, it'd really snake hiss your opponent off!
-
McManusFan
- Posts: 7959
- Joined: 03 October 2018
- Snooker Idol: Alan McManus
- Highest Break: 8
by Scooper » 28 Nov 2021 Read
And especially if like James said, the ref called the frame over beforehand
-
Scooper
- Posts: 4803
- Joined: 15 February 2016
by Pink Ball » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:I assumed that was a mid frame incident, but since the frame is basically over, doesn’t seem as important somehow. Would ding fans really be happy if he won the frame off that?
The frame was not ‘basically over’. The frame is live because of that foul. And yes, I’d have been very happy. Massive reprieve but a deserved one given that it was so stupid of Craigie. Wouldn’t feel a bit sorry for Ding if he lost a frame over being so careless.
-
Pink Ball
- Posts: 22343
- Joined: 07 April 2015
- Location: Galway city, Ireland
- Snooker Idol: You are a banker
- Walk-On: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkfgIUiCiUQ
by Yanfan » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Juddernaut88 wrote:Eurosport are showing the incident.
Doherty and Hendry both say it was a foul. I couldn't tell when I watched it. It was a close call for me.
-
Yanfan
- Posts: 2054
- Joined: 20 November 2021
- Highest Break: 112
- Walk-On: Put Yer Money Where Yer Mouth Is by Oasis
by SnookerEd25 » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Juddernaut88 wrote:It's a foul for me.
Not for me, so it’s subjective isn’t it? In which case the presiding referee makes the call, and she didn’t award a foul. End of story.
-
SnookerEd25
- Posts: 18712
- Joined: 10 October 2011
- Location: West London
- Snooker Idol: Cliff Wilson
- Highest Break: 53
- Walk-On: Play with Fire (Rolling Stones)
by Iranu » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:And especially if like James said, the ref called the frame over beforehand
My issue’s more with the ref than Craigie. But I wouldn’t feel any worse winning a frame from that than from any other opponent’s foul. I’d feel aggrieved to have lost it.
-
Iranu
- Posts: 41485
- Joined: 24 January 2010
- Walk-On: Fort Knox - Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
by Pink Ball » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:And especially if like James said, the ref called the frame over beforehand
Absolute bullocks. How often do you see a referee counting points towards a player’s break, but then reversing that when the cue ball goes in off? Doesn’t happen every day, but happens every tournament.
Secondly, even if that were the rule, it would still technically be a mistake on her part for calling the frame before every ball comes to a halt.
-
Pink Ball
- Posts: 22343
- Joined: 07 April 2015
- Location: Galway city, Ireland
- Snooker Idol: You are a banker
- Walk-On: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkfgIUiCiUQ
by McManusFan » 28 Nov 2021 Read
SnookerEd25 wrote:Juddernaut88 wrote:It's a foul for me.
Not for me, so it’s subjective isn’t it? In which case the presiding referee makes the call, and she didn’t award a foul. End of story.
But it isn't subjective, the rule here is pretty objective.
-
McManusFan
- Posts: 7959
- Joined: 03 October 2018
- Snooker Idol: Alan McManus
- Highest Break: 8
by Dan-cat » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Jan will be giving her some serious punishment about now.
-
Dan-cat
- Posts: 31528
- Joined: 20 August 2013
- Location: Shoreditch, London
- Snooker Idol: The Rocket + The Nugget
- Highest Break: 53
- Walk-On: www.instagram.com/dan_cat
-
by Pink Ball » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Are you guys bucking blind? The white is clearly still rolling. Contrarian fuckery for the sake of contrarian fuckery. This is cut and dry. Craigie screwed up, and she screwed up even more by not calling the buck up.
-
Pink Ball
- Posts: 22343
- Joined: 07 April 2015
- Location: Galway city, Ireland
- Snooker Idol: You are a banker
- Walk-On: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkfgIUiCiUQ
by Pink Ball » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Dan-cat wrote:Jan will be giving her some serious punishment about now.
I know you’re being sarcastic, but I’d imagine she will get a talking to. Snooker referees only have to make a big call once in a blue moon, and she missed hers. I actually think she’s a good referee, but that was a bad miss.
-
Pink Ball
- Posts: 22343
- Joined: 07 April 2015
- Location: Galway city, Ireland
- Snooker Idol: You are a banker
- Walk-On: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkfgIUiCiUQ
by csprince » 28 Nov 2021 Read
it's clearly a foul all craigie has to do is let the white stop or make sure his cue doesn't touch the white.the ref made a mistake.
-
csprince
- Posts: 7620
- Joined: 01 December 2018
- Snooker Idol: DING JUNHUI
- Highest Break: 97
- Walk-On: WHEN DOVES CRY
by Scooper » 28 Nov 2021 Read
I’m not saying it’s definitely right to not call a foul, just that it’s an odd one. And not as definitely wrong as if that happened mid-frame.
-
Scooper
- Posts: 4803
- Joined: 15 February 2016
by Pink Ball » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:I’m not saying it’s definitely right to not call a foul, just that it’s an odd one. And not as definitely wrong as if that happened mid-frame.
IT DOESN’T MATTER WHEN THE buck IT HAPPENS, IT’S THE SAME bucking FOUL!
-
Pink Ball
- Posts: 22343
- Joined: 07 April 2015
- Location: Galway city, Ireland
- Snooker Idol: You are a banker
- Walk-On: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkfgIUiCiUQ
by csprince » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:I’m not saying it’s definitely right to not call a foul, just that it’s an odd one. And not as definitely wrong as if that happened mid-frame.
where in the frame it happened doesn't matter a foul is a foul.
-
csprince
- Posts: 7620
- Joined: 01 December 2018
- Snooker Idol: DING JUNHUI
- Highest Break: 97
- Walk-On: WHEN DOVES CRY
by Scooper » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Pink Ball wrote:Scooper wrote:I’m not saying it’s definitely right to not call a foul, just that it’s an odd one. And not as definitely wrong as if that happened mid-frame.
IT DOESN’T MATTER WHEN THE buck IT HAPPENS, IT’S THE SAME bucking FOUL!
WELL JUST MY BUCKING OPINION, BUT I’LL BE BUCKING LEAVING IT FOR NOW!!!
-
Scooper
- Posts: 4803
- Joined: 15 February 2016
by SnookerFan » 28 Nov 2021 Read
-
SnookerFan
- Posts: 151070
- Joined: 13 December 2009
- Snooker Idol: Michaela Tabb
- Walk-On: Entry Of The Gladiators
-
by Pink Ball » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:Pink Ball wrote:Scooper wrote:I’m not saying it’s definitely right to not call a foul, just that it’s an odd one. And not as definitely wrong as if that happened mid-frame.
IT DOESN’T MATTER WHEN THE buck IT HAPPENS, IT’S THE SAME bucking FOUL!
WELL JUST MY BUCKING OPINION, BUT I’LL BE BUCKING LEAVING IT FOR NOW!!!
YOUR OPINION IS WORTH bucking rubbish WHEN PLACED AGAINST FACTS OF THE MATTER.
-
Pink Ball
- Posts: 22343
- Joined: 07 April 2015
- Location: Galway city, Ireland
- Snooker Idol: You are a banker
- Walk-On: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkfgIUiCiUQ
by HappyCamper » 28 Nov 2021 Read
James Bentley wrote:The referee had called that Craigie had won the frame before he put his cue down, so the frame was over, wasn't it?
correct. the frame had clearly been declared by the ref so what craigie does after that is not a foul.
you can argue that the ref should have waited to call the frame, but craigie would not have placed his cue on the table had she not so the point is moot. it would be wrong to punish craigie for the referee's error in that case.
Last edited by
HappyCamper on 28 Nov 2021, edited 1 time in total.
-
HappyCamper
- Posts: 18812
- Joined: 05 November 2018
- Location: Edinburgh
- Snooker Idol: Graeme Dott
- Walk-On: Banana Chips by Shonen Knife
by Iranu » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:I’m not saying it’s definitely right to not call a foul, just that it’s an odd one. And not as definitely wrong as if that happened mid-frame.
I don’t understand this at all. Surely it’s worse that it happened at the end of the frame? If it happened earlier there would be several more factors determining who won the frame. Craigie won the frame as a direct result of this buck up.
-
Iranu
- Posts: 41485
- Joined: 24 January 2010
- Walk-On: Fort Knox - Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
by csprince » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Scooper wrote:Pink Ball wrote:Scooper wrote:I’m not saying it’s definitely right to not call a foul, just that it’s an odd one. And not as definitely wrong as if that happened mid-frame.
IT DOESN’T MATTER WHEN THE buck IT HAPPENS, IT’S THE SAME bucking FOUL!
WELL JUST MY BUCKING OPINION, BUT I’LL BE BUCKING LEAVING IT FOR NOW!!!
if that was the final frame of the final it would be a foul and the ref would be crucified.either the shot is legal or a foul regardless when in the frame it happened.
-
csprince
- Posts: 7620
- Joined: 01 December 2018
- Snooker Idol: DING JUNHUI
- Highest Break: 97
- Walk-On: WHEN DOVES CRY
by Dan-cat » 28 Nov 2021 Read
Pink Ball wrote:Dan-cat wrote:Jan will be giving her some serious punishment about now.
I know you’re being sarcastic, but I’d imagine she will get a talking to. Snooker referees only have to make a big call once in a blue moon, and she missed hers. I actually think she’s a good referee, but that was a bad miss.
I meant it seriously, but also wanted to hint at some possible S+M business.
-
Dan-cat
- Posts: 31528
- Joined: 20 August 2013
- Location: Shoreditch, London
- Snooker Idol: The Rocket + The Nugget
- Highest Break: 53
- Walk-On: www.instagram.com/dan_cat
-
by Pink Ball » 28 Nov 2021 Read
HappyCamper wrote:James Bentley wrote:The referee had called that Craigie had won the frame before he put his cue down, so the frame was over, wasn't it?
correct. the frame had clearly been declared by the ref so what craigie does after that is not a foul.
you can argue that the ref should have waited to call the frame, but craigie would not have placed his cue on the table had she not so the point is moot. it would be wrong to punish craigie for the referee's error in that case.
I don’t understand this logic. So a player is on a break of 9, pots the black, the ref calls the break at 16, white rolls in off, but the break is still 16 because the ref declared it so?
-
Pink Ball
- Posts: 22343
- Joined: 07 April 2015
- Location: Galway city, Ireland
- Snooker Idol: You are a banker
- Walk-On: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkfgIUiCiUQ