Post a reply

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby vodkadiet

Most overrated by a mile is O'Sullivan, followed by Trump.

Most underrated is Mark King.

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby Bourne

Overrated - Selby, not even close tbh
Underrated - Fu, including by me, he's just annoyingly, consistently good.

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby randam05

I think under rated is definatley Fu, not sure on over rated really...

ACTUALLY i am sure...COPE!! so over rated.

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby GJ

Overrated - Selby and maguire
Underrated - Dott

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby GJ

Witz78 wrote:most over rated player is..

trump



I thought you were a fan of his witz :huh: :roll:

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby randam05

GJ wrote:Overrated - Selby and maguire
Underrated - Dott


Ah yes, maguire a good call there and same with dott. <ok>

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby Bourne

GJ wrote:
Witz78 wrote:most over rated player is..

trump



I thought you were a fan of his witz :huh: :roll:

I see what you did there :hatoff:

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby jojo

in terms of the most overrated player i can pick from a few without meaning to sound disrespectful such as trump cope and selby

i know trump is still very very young but he should be winning more matches than he is doing im not necessarily saying tournaments this for someone who gets so much attention and hype

similarly cope why he not win anything yet ? when the going get tough and requires matchplay he not there and as for selby again he something like 26 27 and only won one welsh open which not exactly a major ranker even though he has won two masters

as for the most underrated player again quite a few to choose from fu being an obvious one i would even say someone like doherty because of the players he had to contend with in his era he still won his fair share of titles

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby SnookerFan

What's overrated about Mark Allen? :huh: He's a consistent semi-finalist, who many have said just needs a bit more confidence to win a ranking event. I'd say that was a pretty solid assessment. It's not like anyone is out there claiming he's going to be a multiple world champion or anything.

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby sundaygirl

Mark Allen is an excellent player nothing wrong with his game, but I don't think he is a winner. When ever he does reach a semi people tip him to go on and win but...

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby GJ

missed out carter if stevens is overratted so is carter less achievements than matthew and a similar age

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby Monique

GJ wrote:missed out carter if stevens is overratted so is carter less achievements than matthew and a similar age


There was never much hype around Carter, while there was a lot around Stevens ... but he's in the top 16 and Matthew isn't and hasn't been for quite a while.

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby Roland

wheelsofsteel wrote:most over-rated - Selby, Carter, Allen, Trump

most under-rated - Dott, Fu

most hated - let's not go there


I'd go with that apart from Selby obviously as I'm one seen to over rate him :redneck:

He nearly won the German Masters playing at 80%

Re: Who do people think the...

Postby randam05

wheelsofsteel wrote:
Tubberlad wrote:Most overated: Cope
Underated: Dott, nobody comes close


how could I forget Cope :ashamed:


He is certainly the most over rated.