Who's Superior?

As per the poll choices.

Alan.

He won The Masters.

McManus won 2 rankers and the Masters and Hawkins won 3 rankers. You could say the Masters win puts McManus above Hawkins but Hawkins on the other hand showed more consistency at the World Championship.

Its either McManus by a tiny margin or similar quality. I voted similar quality.

Similar quality, can't really separate the two.