paperbackwriter wrote:Surely it's nice to watch a player who tries to do his best in every tournament but in my opinion exaggeration is just as possible here. You cross the line and instead of being a real fighter and getting people excited- you become silly and totally uncool. And trying to make some of his achievements look more important than they really are or refusing to give up in no-win situations in non-ranking events (which isn't very likely to draw potential fans to snooker) means that Murphy is on the bad side here- at least for me. (It's probably also about the way in which he does all of this- doesn't really look like the attitude that is missed so much these days.)
Yeah, I think a player lauding it after a win, no matter what the tournament is, isn't on. I'd prefer to see a player congratulating his opponent etc and turning up focussed for the next event.
Without seeing it, the trying to win when that far done incident seems unneccessary. You clearly aren't go to win. I was one of those people who defended Alain Robidoux in that controversial frame, because he was 8-2 behind, about to go 9-2 in a first to ten match. Slight gamesmanship, perhaps, but trying to keep your opponent off the table a bit, try and throw him off for the last frame. On re-watching it on Youtube years later, it's only because it's Ronnie anybody remembers it... However, to do this in the middle of a match like Murphy did seems less understandable. Especially in a tournament like this. Wanting to minors is good, giving it your all is good, snake hissing about for no reason, not so good. I could understand if it was in the last frame or two, trying anything to get back into it... But by the sounds of it, that's not what Murphy was doing.